Church, state and locality: revisiting the historiography of “state” and “religious infrastructures” in England and Wales, 1740-1870
Martin, Mary Clare (2011) Church, state and locality: revisiting the historiography of “state” and “religious infrastructures” in England and Wales, 1740-1870. In: International Standing Committee of the History of Education. 33rd conference. State, education and society: new perspectives on an old debate, 26-29 Jul 2011, San Luis Potosi, Mexico. (Unpublished)
ischeJune2011.docx - Draft Version
Restricted to Repository staff only
The historiographical tradition which developed within the history of education has regarded religious organisations as distractions from the real task of developing state-funded universal education. Within this paradigm, Britain fared poorly, as until and after the 1870s, most or many schools for the poor were funded by religious societies, notably the National Society and the BFSS, akin to modern-day national charities, The “discovery” by Philip Gardner in 1984 of working class schooling reinforced the view that National and British schools were avoided in favour of working class private schools. Yet this finding was not confirmed by the Newcastle Commission of 1858.
The”voluntary” schools have been characterised as intended agents of social control, with low standards and brutal discipline. The questions raised by dissenters such as Harold Silver, who questioned whether standards of discipline were brutal, and noted the diversity of inspectors’ reports, have not been pursued. Yet in the English context, the parish was the unit of organisation of “the state” at local level, and for the dispensing of relief, especially before the New Poor law of 1836. From the 1690s onwards, schools, built as adjuncts to churches and chapels, became centres of parish life, places where welfare was dispensed, locations for parish libraries as well as local entertainments.
This paper will draw on the author’s case-study of two “commuter villages” on the outskirts of London, between 1740-1870, to call for a re-conceptualisation of the place of the voluntary school within parish life. Indubitably, there was a regional specificity about this location: near London, with opportunities for employment in crafts, trades and service as well as the metropolis. Nevertheless, as many studies have been located, either in areas of heavy industry, or in rural areas, this provides an opportunity for a contrasting perspective.
|Item Type:||Conference or Workshop Item (Paper)|
|Additional Information:|| To be published in the "ISCHE memoirs."|
|Uncontrolled Keywords:||church, state, locality, school, religion|
|Subjects:||L Education > L Education (General)
L Education > LA History of education
|School / Department / Research Groups:||School of Education
Faculty of Education & Health > School of Education
School of Education > Department of Education & Community Studies
Faculty of Education & Health > School of Education > Department of Education & Community Studies
|Last Modified:||16 Feb 2015 16:20|
Actions (login required)
Downloads per month over past year