Europeanization, EU conditionality and governance quality: empirical evidence on Central and Eastern European Countries

Ugur, Mehmet (2013) Europeanization, EU conditionality and governance quality: empirical evidence on Central and Eastern European Countries. International Studies Quarterly. ISSN 0020-8833 (print), 1468-2478 (Online) (In Press)

PDF - Accepted Version Restricted to Repository staff only Download (230kB)

Abstract

A large body of work within the Europeanization and conditionality literature has examined EU’s effect on governance quality in Central and Eastern European countries (CEECs). This article aims to contribute to existing work by addressing two questions. First, was EU’s accession conditionality conducive to better governance in CEECs or was it designed to pick up already committed reformers? Secondly, during which period was the EU more influential on governance quality in CEECs: accession or membership? To address these questions, we propose a simple model of moral hazard and adverse selection, and draw on survey-based governance quality data to test its predictions. We report that the EU has offered candidate status to countries that already had better governance quality relative to their peers before 1997. Nonetheless, EU conditionality also had some positive effects on CEEC governance during the accession period, but this effect tended to disappear during the membership period. On the basis of these findings, we argue that EU’s impact on governance quality in CEECs has to be examined in conjunction with path dependence and therefore the perceived risk of ‘backsliding’ requires more detailed analysis.

Actions (login required)